The Genocide Of Ideas
by Ian R Thorpe
17 April 2012
The mind of one freethinker can possess a million ideas, the minds of a million fanatics can be posessed by a single idea: - Anon.
Interviewed on UK Television the director and former Monty Python Flying Circus member Terry Gilliam said he did not like anything among the recent output from Hollywood.
"I don't know what they are about," he complained, "there is a car chase, a few fights, a threat to civilisation and the hero saves the world." Continuing to critique the formulaic Hollywood blockbuster genre Gilliam said films, books and plays ought to be about ideas.
His own work has never been short of ideas, the dystopian vision of "Brazil" made in 1985 and now hailed as "prescient" due to so many of its depictions of social dysfunction having become reality, is a fine example of how his films tackle ideas that ought to be difficult to bring to the screen even for directors with Hollywood blockbuster sized SFX budgets to play with. Gilliam manages to pull off such unlikely fantasies as Brazil, Baron Munchausen and the more recent extravaganza The Imaginarium of Dr.Parnassus simply because he understands ideas. Realism and authenticity go out of the window but the images communicate the idea successfully.
If Franz Kafka had been an animator and film director and perhaps a member of Monty Python's Flying Circus he might have made films like those of Terry Gilliam. Brazil depicts the kind of outrageously dystopian satire one could easily imagine Kafka writing about. Time and again Gilliam captures visually the paranoid-subversive spirit of Kafka's The Trial in this nightmare-comedy about a meek government clerk named Sam Lowry (Jonathan Pryce) in a bureaucratic dictatorship, whose life is destroyed by a simple bug. Not a software bug but a real bug of the same genre perhaps as Kafka's Metamorphosis insect, that gets squashed in a printer and causes a typographical error unjustly identifying an innocent citizen, one Mr Buttle, as suspected terrorist Harry Tuttle (Robert De Niro). When Sam becomes involved in unravelling this bureaucratic tangle, he himself winds up labelled as a criminal. The movie presents such an unrelentingly imaginative and savage vision of late 20th-century bureaucracy and it's implacable demands and for conformity and total compliance with myriad trivial and pointless rules and regulations that it almost became a victim of bureaucratically minded studio management itself, until Gilliam surreptitiously screened his cut for the Los Angeles Film Critics Association, who named it the best movie of 1985 and thus coerced Universal into releasing it.
But how did Gilliam learn to make such movies? Surely he must have attended some very special school or perhaps at art college been a student of somebody who studied under Salvador Dali or Luis Bunuel. Actually no, he had a standard renaissance education based on the same model as Shakespeare, Isaac Newton, JMW Turner and Thomas Edison. Sometimes known misleadingly as the liberal arts education this model curriculum aims to provide a broad grounding in language, mathematics, natural sciences and culture that will equip the pupil to pursue a variety of interests in later life. The aim of this education method is to produce well rounded individuals by encouraging pupils to learn by themselves rather that force feeding a diet of dry facts and forcing curious, lively young minds to specialist at far too early a stage in their development.
One of the reasons why education has "dumbed down so much over recent decades is that the shroud of a giant central bureaucracy rests heavily on the minds of pupils and teachers alike, imposing dull conformity, obsessing over targets, statistics and league tables instead of teaching. I used to notice the marked difference
As an information technology manager I used to notice the marked difference between young people who came to us from private schools or areas in which the local authority had retained some independence and still operated a selection at eleven policy, sending the brighter pupils into a system in which they would receive that broad education and benefit from it, and those from areas whose schools operated the standard state education curriculum. The ones from private schools were gobby, confident, sometimes a pain in the arse but they were in love with learning, glad of for the privilege of being able to ask experts in their field about developing software, may stem in which managing data and operating networks in my department, in others about engineering, business administration, design, research and development and a range range far beyond the designated field of practical inquiry governed by the the need to pass an impending test. The ordinary state school pupils were sullen, resentful, liable to go missing for whole days, disinterested and regarded the whole exercise as an imposition.
Now defenders of the state system might say that the pupils I found rewarding enjoyed comfortable homes and a high standard of living provided by affluent parents at all times, had unlimited access to libraries, and benefited from the latest technology to assist them in pursuing their studies. It was the old mantra of the left satirised by Steven Sondheim in West Side Story with the line "I'm depraved because I'm deprived," But did the children from poorer homes not feel an even greater incentive to learn and so increase their chances of getting out of the poverty trap. Alas it was not so. They had no ideas you see, their education, with it's heavy emphasis on , equal rights and other irrelevancies had inculcated dependency on the state and the authorities. It had been drummed into them that individual enterprise was somehow to be frowned on. They had learned we are not being fair and equalitarian if we have ambition.
Another thing I noted, to get back to Terry Gilliam's point is that in their literary studies, the privately educated pupils had been introduced to the classics, were familiar with Chaucer and Milton, could discuss religions and ethics critically and usually had an understanding of our intellectual history, incorporating the wisdom and intelligence of the larger culture that ultimately sustains us, the world in which we live and which so many are encouraged to take for granted. This caveat applies to members of the teaching profession which has largely surrendered to the idiotic notion of student “empowerment” and other politically correct notions as a way of maintaining the status quo by failing to teach ways of learning so that pupils can develop as individuals after leaving full time education and that is simultaneously busy undermining social structures, personal independence, intellectual rigor, and the quest for determinate truth. These teachers’ pedagogical rationale is passed of as “social justice” and “postmodern indeterminacy,” but is really encouraging solipsism. Academics who advise government on education policy tend to be regarded as “experts in the field,” but as Primo Levi said in The Monkey’s Wrench, “I never saw an expert who was any good.”
It is worth mentioning that the set reading on the school literature curriculum now shows a strong left wing bias. Novels about racism, trade union struggles against the evils of capitalism, turgid feminist tomes, books about disability and a whole library of stories about poverty and oppression abound. There is nothing there to present a broader picture of human life, to suggest that other points of view may be valid.
Educationalists, and the teachers lower down the pecking order do not understand the private education sector cannot provide enough highly educated people to keep a modern society running not can those people contribute enough in taxes to support the great uneducated mass who have been given only one idea, that they should never have to do anything they do not want to do, to steer them through life.
The bond between teacher and student has completely unravelled. The unwritten covenant between the participants in the noble game of intellectual discourse has been superseded by a mutual understanding that the life of a "disadvantaged person" should by right be based on the instant gratification of impulses and that to try to offer another way based on self discipline and personal responsibility is a violation of human rights.. The teacher has to assume the role of surrogate parent, counsellor, therapist and nursemaid to classes of unwilling, disruptive and easily distracted who "know their rights" but little else.
This malaise extends into the university system. Few graduates emerge without having their heads fill with Marxism - lite ideology while employers are complaining that degree studies are so dumbed down they no longer offer an advantage in the jobs market. With occupations such as writing, acting or film making now being degree entry professions is it any wonder Terry Gilliam complains of a dearth of ideas. Experience has been replaced by indoctrination. What we are seeing is the paranoia of the new elite in action. Having emerged as a new social class the managerial and public sector professions now fear losing the control they have established. Knowing their ancestors struggled out of poverty and drudgery only two or three generations ago they now fear the descendents of those who were left behind.
As technology puts the squeeze on skilled jobs and globalisation means the labouring classes are priced out of the market, this academic and managerial elite are eliminating the competition. In the 1950s and 60s, when I was growing up, there was far more social mobility, more opportunity for people from the lower levels of society to improve their lot, than there is now, in spite of all the politically correct blabber about fairness and equality. And ideas were traded freely, developed, personalised and cherished.
Free Speech And The 'Black Lives Matter' Book Burners
The news that students and administrators at a Connecticut, USA, university are ‘boycotting’ the Wesleyan Argus student newspaper for publishing an op-ed that was mildly critical of some aspects of the anti-police-brutality group Black Lives Matter (BLM). Their petition reads: ‘This boycott includes recycling the Argus and demanding [its] funds… be revoked.’
Philo and Sophia - The Page For Lovers Of Wisdom
You might find some of the more bizarre fringes of philosophy and thought from history and from around the world here here, among the original thinking of our contributors. As with most pages in The Greenteeth Labyrinth this is not a page for academics or conventional students but for explorers and people who like to play with fresh or off - centre ideas.
Eight Subjects That Ought To Be Part Of The Manadtory Curriculum For Basic Education?
Should subjects like meditation and gardening be part of the school currriculum? Or as one high school in Massachusetts, USA, seems to believe, classes in analyzing conspiracy theories (if taught properly this could help students distinguish between a true conspiracy theory, a fantasy and what is legitimate questioning of official propaganda. The embedded article from Collective Evolution presents some interesting ideas.
British Democracy In Terminal Decline - Voting Is Redundant And Civil Liberties Are So Last Year
When did democracy go out of fashion. I don't remember voting on whether we wanted to give up our civil liberties or be ruled by a dictatorship of unelected bureaucrats from Brussels, but that is where we are heading, along with the other free nations of Europe. And the USA, so-called land of the free is further along the road to fascism than Europe.
Britain’s maths policy simply doesn’t add up - but neither does overestimating the importance of maths.
As an engineer, mathematics has been an important part of my career but I have always been aware that it is a tool. In the past there have been many attempts to develop a 'philosophy of everything' base on mathematical speculations that took maths into areas it was never designed to go, areas of human thought and enquiry that rightly belong to philosophers. This talk of mathematicians being creative jarrs with me somewhat, inventors, engineers, designers are creative. Mathematics is just part of our tool kit.
How Fundamentalists Of Materialism Hijacked Science.
Yet again we find ourselves making a stand against the fascism of mainstream science. The nerds are getting stroppy and trying to suppress ideas they don't like again (Nobody expects The Science Inquisition) Thing is of course, if their ideas were half as good as they claim, the alternative being proposed would not look so convincing.
The First humans From Australia Not Africa?
Weez Allz From Africa? Sorry But Weez Isn't - another discovery throws doubt on the established narrative of human history. It would be no surprise to find the version of history told by academics and schoolteacher is wrong, but in fact we simply can't say. Given the movements of the eath's crust over millions of years, the first humans could easily be at the bottom of the ocean. All we know for certain is nothing can be proved for certain. here's the case for Australia.
Has Human Evolution Stopped - Are We Now Masters Of Our Own Destiny
The usual arguments around the topic of evolution revolve on the science versus religion war, did we evolve or were we created? That is really an unsatisfactory debate because unless the ancient texts of many religions are interpreted literally then the Big Bang could have been the result of an act of creation while evolution addresses the diversity of life, not its origin. When we consider the question of whether modern biology has made evolution obsolete however, that is fertile ground for those who like to speculate.
The Arrogance Of The New Elite
In the last few days I've been busy winding up the Sheeple who always obey The Guardian and so have tried to brand UKIP a racist party. One of the memes has been "UKIP have no policies apart from quitting Europe". This is pretty rich coming from people who are telling us we must vote for
A Unified Theory of Evolution – How Karma & Reincarnation Complete Darwinism & Intelligent Design - Weird science
Supporters of Big bang and Evolution and the people who believe in The Creation as described in The Bible, or perhaps in Intelligent Design could ner find common ground could they? It would be too much to expect followers of Isaac Newton't materialism and the determinist philosophy closely linked to it to suddenly start agreing, but many scientific researchers whose work takes them to the outer limits of human knowledge are exploring very interesting territory.
Is Biocentrism The Theory Of Everything And Does It Prove There Is Life After death - Weird science
Newtonian materialism and determinism, the orthodox creed of The Church of Scientism, is obviously as wrong scientifically as the idea that God created the universe in seven days arounf 6,000 years ago. While religious metaphor is perfectly acceptable to me, when I question the dogma of science, the science worshippers shout heretic and start a medieval witch hunt. Yet thee are many scientifically and logically sound ideas that offer better answers than determinism.
The International Elite's Contempt For National Sovereignty
One of our themes in The Daily Stirrer has been the new elise and their push for global government. Here in a cross post with Philo and Sophia we look at the political philosophy behind multiculturalism global view thinking and the push to abolish national sovereignty and hand power to supranational bureaucrats
New World Order War On free Speech Comes To Britain - Guardian editor accused of treason
The right to free speech is under threat from intolerant, authoritarian elitists, call them The Illuminati, New World Order, Scientific Dictatorshgip, Global Elite, whatever. Their goal is absolute power and they know that while the right of free speech, the free press and free access to information exist they cannot succeed.
How American Forces Network Saved Our Lives
Britain in the 1950s was a monochrome society, a rigid, unyielding social order and overt class consciousness constrained social interactions, people were reluctant to do the right thing for fear of it being deemed by "polite society" as the wrong thing. Fortunately a radio station we should not have been listening to, and the subversive music it played took the lead in releasing us from our bonds
Brand Plays A Blinder And Paxo Gets Stuffed
The recent and very highly publicised attacks by Russell Brand on corporate fascism, political corruption, the whoring of science and the destruction of democracy do not hail the advent of a new messiah of the working class. Instead they show how out - of - touch the elite of right and left, politicians, business leaders, the media actually are. These people are totally unaware of the realities of life for ordinary people.
Is It Lack Of Diversity That Drives Liberal Hate And Intolerance
Quantum Soul: Is Each Of Us A Part Of The Universe
Anyone who has spent time in political threads online, especially in the comments under articles on topics like abortion, same sex marriage, climate change, GM crops, vaccines and race related issues will be familiar with the phenomonon of liberal and left wing hate attacks. What used to be the politics of tolerance, free speech and democracy has become the politics of intolerance and authoritarinism with even the slightest and most reasoned dissent provoking orchestrated Nazi and Fascist style hate attacks. So what's the problem with these so called liberals?
Religious and secular philopsophers have argued for centuries about life beyond death, the nature of the human soul and our relationshi[p with God, the universe or whatever. Modern militant secularists have tried to claim we are nothing more than machines, others say life is a chemical accident but experience tells most people there is much more to our existence than that ...
Captive Minds, Conformity and Cowardly IntellectualOne of the most disturbing things about this era of [politically correct thinking, left wing concensus and multiculturalis is the absence of divrtsity in the opinions of people in academic life, politoics, the media and the professions.
Champagne Socialists, who are they, what progressive or liberal political ideals do they stand for, do these fabled lefties actually exist or are they a modern myth. The Daily Stirrer goes in pursuit of Champagne Socialists
I am not a Marxist, that does not make me a creationist. I am not a creationist, that does not make me a Marxist.Sunday morning is a lazy time for those who have no young children and no interest in religion. Every Sunday, in a slot that was for years occupied by a Christian religious program Mrs. T and I like to watch the wider discussion show that now fills that hour as we consume a leisurely breakfast. One thing that strikes me in these discussions is that the secular view is often represented by a "scientist" who labours under the misapprehension that all who participate in worship or do not subscribe to Marxist thinking are creationists.
These stupid laws insult the public and threaten free speech
When the law forbids us to insult or offend somebody, to insult or offend a religion, race, skin colour or sexual preference, free speech and other important democratic rights are under threat. When the law then goes on to say that anyone accused of these offences has no right to defend themselves and the word of the accuser is sufficient evidence on which to obtain a conviction then we have abandoned justice and are ruled by fascists.
Creativity Must Triumph Over ConformityBruce Elkin argues that to save civilisation creativity must triumph over conformity. We must kick our addiction to consumption, rediscover the things that are really important and use the unique abilities of humans to create a society in which fullfillment is the goal rather than wealth and power. In other words we must redefine what we mean by success.
Why The Intellectual Elitie Truly Despise The Lower ClassesHave you noticed that the professional hand wriners of the left have shifted their focus from 'the poor' to minorities. They did not succeed in abolishing poverty so what's going on? Simples. The intellectual left having elected themselves to speak for the poor found the poor were able to speakl for themselves and resented posh pokenoses pontification about matters of which understanding cannot be gained by reading books. This article exposes the hypocrisy of the left ...
Mathematics and RealityIn all of our blogs and web sites the Greenteeth team have been critical of those science fans who are turning science into a religion. Scientists deny this of course even in the face of the evidence. Here Ian R Thorpe shows you that the idea of mathematics as God is nothing new, it has been around longer than Christianity in fact.
We told you so, University Degrees Are WorthlessnThe Daily Stirrer has been saying it for years, now a leading British businessman has come out and said it too. University Degrees are worthless.Self-made multimillionaire Simon Dolan left school at the age of 16 and went on to form a business empire which now turns over close to £100m a year, putting him 703rd on the Sunday Times Rich List. Mr. Dolan also criticised the designer degree business that is responsible for creating such oddball courses as waste management with dance. He described these and even the less insane courses like ...
If Your Kids Are Crap At School It Probably Means ...... they are smarter than the average chav.
Children whose minds wander might have sharper brains, some new scientific research suggests. Now we at Boggart Blog are not keen on crap science or the science of stating the effing obvious which this study.
The Gods Of Copybook HeadingsRudyard Kipling has long been dismissed as an inperialist and a racist. Perhapse it is time for a reappraisal of his work. The very prescient poem reproduced and discussed here warns of the inevitable consequences when "progressives" try to change human nature by passing laws.
The Flight From FreedomFleeing from freedom seems like a contradiction, after all we usually asdsiciate flight with escaping from captivity. In this first part of Existentialism for Beginners however the author identifies a human instinct that predisposes us to seek illusory safety by conforming and being part of the crowd rather than embarking on the lonely life of the free thinker, the person who truly makes their own decisions and follows their own path.
The Coalition Must Not Be Sucked Into The 'Progressive' Left' War On The Family
Since before the 1970s, since before the communists overthrew the Tsar in Russia, since the day Kark Marx condemnede faily life in his Communist Manifesto, the left or 'progressive left' as they now style themselves has been making war on family life and promoting the usurpation of the role of parents by the agencies of the state.
Children Failing At Reading Is Child Abuse By The Education System
In the latest propaganda spiel from the Ministry of Truth, Education Branch a masterpiece of understatement may be found. The bulletin states that the reading skills of junior school pupils must be improved. Sir Michael Wilshaw, head of the Minis Education Branch said, “One in five primary schoolchildren moving up from primary schools is not ready for secondary school. One in five, 20%. Surely they can't all be affected by ...
Education Is Overrated
It's official, education is a waste of time. New figures show that graduates are just as likely to end up on the dole as those leaving the local chav academy with only an ASBO to their name.
The Two Faces Of The Politics Of Failure
What a mess the modern way of doing politics based on a politically correct consensus and social engineering has produced. The daily stirrer looks at how the bipolar left - right divide stops things getting better rather than helping get the developed world back on track.
Queer Theory" Dominates Government Consultation On Same Sex Marriage
Queer theory is an idea floated by left wing shirt- lifting academics that says if the gay lobby keep pumping their propaganda at us people will eventully believe it is more acceptable to be homosexual than straight. That is the tactic of Nazi propagandist Josef Goebbels. Let the limp writed Nazis be known for what they are. There is absolutely nothing wrong with being homosexual but we just wish they wpould shut the fuck up about it.
Science, Certanties and Stereotypes
The left are always quick to accuse their opponents of stereotyping but when it comes to embracing certainties and applying stereotypes there is no political group worse than the left, which includes the supporters of politicised science and the miolitant atheists for stereotyping their opponents as a way to suppress views opposed to their own. ...
Schools Failing To Promote Reading Of Classic Literature
Less than one in 100 teenagers who took the most popular English literature course and sat the A level examination last year chose to answer questions on novels published prior to 1900, says Michael Gove, Education Secretary in the Coalition government. Only 1,236 out of 300,000 students read Pride and Prejudice, 285 studied Far From the Madding Crowd and just 187 completed Wuthering Heights as part of ...
Maths Teachers In English Schools Are Crap At Maths
Our headline comes from a major two-year study published today which reports that student teachers in England had achieved a poorer standard in mathematics than trainees in nations such as China, Japan, Ireland, Finland and Russia ...
Universities Should Not Be Asked To Repair Society
Should university education provide therapy for damaged children from deprived homes, a teacher asks as the politically correct though police demand the system be skewed in favour of the fuckwits and under achievers in the name of 'equality.'
Sonnet for Mr. Edwards
Philo and Sophia, the philosophy menu
more on Politically Correct fascism
more posts on Education