Mathematics and Realityby Ian R Thorpe25 April 2012Marcus du Sautoy, Mathematician, Professor for the Public Understanding of Science (having succeeded Richard Dawkins in the Chair) last year presented a series of TV programmes about mathematics and nature entitled ‘The Code’. Advance publicity for the show led potential viewers to believe Prof. Du Sautoy would be presenting a mainstream view of mathematics in an attempt to demonstrate the subject is not really as difficult or nerdy as people think, rather than promoting his own very nerdy version of atheistic metaphysics. Du Sautoy is not so much a mathematician, he's a maths geek. In the televised debate on why British pupils in the state education system are failing so badly in Mathematics, Marcus du Sautoy opened for the pro maths side and demolished his own case in his first sentence, saying: “When Wayne Rooney takes a shot at goal he first does a simultaneous equation.” Now Wayne Rooney is one of our finest soccer players and probably the best goalscorer of his generation. But he is not the brightest light on the Christmas Tree. While a wonderful, instinctive athlete in his chosen sport it's doubtful he even knows what an equation is. So can we imagine him pausing to do complex algebraic calculations in his head in the split second he has to steady himself and strike the ball. I think not. Can you imagine a sports commentator raving: “ ... and the ball comes to Rooney. He does an equation, he shoots, he scores.” It's laughable. Cats catching their prey, dogs catching a Frisbee in mid air and horses taking a fence so high they cannot see the ground on the other side would also have to do equations, not one but many. And if Wayne Rooney does not seem capable of such a mental exercise those creatures certainly aren't. Few of us are taken in by Du Sautoy's hyperbolic overselling of mathematics. Having read articles and essays Du Sautoy has published, he seems to be a rather cranky academic who is totally besotted with his specialist subject. In his published work he has made such outrageous claims as because music can be mathematically analysed, without mathematics we could not have created music and that the Universe is constructed according to a very complex mathematical design (nothing outrageous about that you might think but he and his supporters deny this is just a version of intelligent design, dismissing intelligent design as religious nonsense). Du Sautoy’s view of the physical dimension is that, as the Pythagoreans expressed it, ‘Number is everything.’ This is not as original as you might think, in fact it has been around since the ancient Geek Pythagoras (570 - 490 BC) floated it as an answer to the religious and naturalistic schools of philosophy. Pythagoras was a scientist, a mathematician in fact, so as far as Marcus Du Sautoy is concerned, QED. The idea that everything emanates from numbers and mathematics is clearly as undemonstrable as the Biblical creation story or Big Bang theory. This should make the proposition anathema to a mathematician and identify it as a faith-based religious concept. Philosophers of mathematics and informed students of mathematics know that there is, to date, no satisfactory understanding of the relationship, if any, between mathematics and reality; to suggest that there is a relationship, and what such a relationship might be, is an act of faith. And yet, more and more we see, especially among theoretical physicists and mathematicians (and of course among the Climate Science lobby who base their studies on mathematical models rather than observations of reality) that "Science" is becoming more and more like a religion. It is very unfortunate that scientists working with speculative mathematics are behaving as though mathematics is the original reality to which the physical world ‘must’ conform through such things as ‘laws’. Science has been hideously corrupted in the last 80 years because of this and further corrupted through it's becoming a branch of government which has brought into it an element of The King's New Clothes". It is not politically expedient to question science. Many Christians will be delighted to see and hear Du Sautoy suggesting that numbers are at the root of all reality, this is in some ways adds a of kind of scientific endorsement to the theory of Intelligent Design. However Du Sautoy is an avowed atheist who says he intends to is take a more gentle approach to undermining religious belief than Richard ‘The Rottweiler’ Dawkins (whom all can see is a bigoted fanatic) and is not citing design, or even apparent design, as the basis of everything but referring to some mysterious entity he calls ‘The Code’. A code at the very least implies information content, but The Code (as a proper noun and with the definite article) suggests something unique and powerful. God? In his own words Du Sautoy puts it like this "…underlying everything that surrounds us, from the natural world to the cities we live in, there is a hidden code that explains why things look and behave they way they do. This hidden code (‘The Code’) has the power to unlock the laws that govern the universe. The Code is the truth of the universe, and its numbers dictate the way the world must be." So, this hidden code, this entity that Du Sautoy calls ‘The Code’ is identical to Absolute Truth, The Oneness, The Ancient Of Days, and can lead us to All Truth, and is completely deterministic. This is unquestionably a religious view of the Universe. In fact it is the old heresy of Pythagoras, the pagan Greek philosopher, re-worked by gnostics, Kabbalists, Freemasons, Rosicrucians, Illuminists, and now, it appears, New Atheists. What a great scam it will be if modern scientists s can pull it one off! Most people know very little about Pythagorean philosophy other than the Pythagorean Theorem of the triangle, which was attributed to Pythagoras, but was most certainly known and used for well over 1000 years before Pythagoras lived. The man himself however was rather more complex than a triangle and apart from believing that the universe and everything in it was made out of numbers and mathematical formulas he also never ate beans because he believed every time we fart a little bit of our soul escapes. Bertrand Russell, the twentieth century mathematician and philosopher, whilst unsympathetic to Pythagoras' view of the nature of things, stated. "I do not know of any other man who has been as influential as he was in the sphere of thought." Pythagoras and his followers believed that all relationships could be reduced to numerical equations, that mathematics (holos) is the true reality, while the world (cosmos) with time and space and all other manner of artifice is a nothing more than a construct of human minds. Pythagorean metaphysics stated that ‘The Essence of Being Is Number’, number being understood to be ‘that which prior to all things subsists…by which and from which all things are coordinated, and remain connumerated in an indissoluble order.’ (Christians will notice a usurpation of the divine Logos therein). The Pythagorean philosophy was dominated by the ideal that numbers were not merely symbols of reality, but were the final substance of real things. Aristotle fleshes this out in his Metaphysics, where he states that the Pythagoreans "…believed that the principles of mathematics were also the principles of all things that be. Now, since the principles of mathematics are numbers, and they thought they found in numbers, more than in fire and earth and water, similarities with things that are and that become (they judged, for example, that justice was a particular property of numbers, the soul and mind another, opportunity another, and similarly, so to say, anything else), and since furthermore they saw expressed by numbers the properties and the ratios of harmony, since finally everything in nature appeared to them to be similar to numbers, and numbers appeared to be first among all there is in nature, they thought that the elements of numbers were the elements of all that there is, and that the whole world was harmony and number." While pagans both modern and ancient, do not believe in their gods as followers of the Abrahamic religions, the Pythagoreans definitely believed in an omnipotent, omniescent God who is in fact a number or numeric code. Allocated a generous budget by the BBC from funds generously but involuntarily donated by taxpayers Du Sautoy starts his series with an expensive jolly to Chartres cathedral, said to be first of the great Gothic cathedrals (in fact Durham Cathedral in north east England was begun first but not completed until after Chartres because of local problems about who was the rightful King of England. Chartres has become far more widely known in recent years thanks to a certain fictional work.
In the Middle Ages the cathedral school at Chartres, like most of the religious communities, was the centre for learning and for a revival and development of Pythagorean ideas. The monastic orders were fiercely independent of the Vatican and openly defied Papal control freakery especially if it related to suppression of ancient knowledge deemed "ungodly" by The Holy Father. Chartes cathedral was built on the site of a Druid temple, the crypt beneath the cathedral being a dolmenic chamber. Diodorus Siculus, writing in 36 BC, describes how these Druids followed Pythagorean teachings although that is probably wrong - the Druids, like the Babylonians, Egyptians, Assyrians, Persians and Minoans were using Pythagorean mathematics long before Pythagoras was even a twinkle in his Daddy's eye. Thanks to such links to a mysterious era in human development, Chartres has become one of the main centres for people interested in the The Grail Mystery and certain lost arts and sciences. The cathedral contains a mass of Masonic, gnostic, pagan, astrological and Pythagorean symbols. As this stuff is the bread and butter of Dan Brown's The Da Vinci Code and the genre of revelatory fiction it spawned along with the speculative history books concerning The Holy Grail, The Knights Templar, Ark Of The Covenant, Freemasonry, Pagan symbols in Christian art and the secrets of the ancients perhaps Chartres was not the most helpful place to start a series that claimed it would reveal a great spiritual truth.
Down the centuries the Abbots of Chartres tried to ‘Christianize’ some of the Pythagorean ideas and make use of them in theology, hence as Otto von Simson (The Gothic Cathedral, Harper & Row, New York, 1956) states,
Stucki obviously thinks Pythagoreans mathematical theology still has followers; Du Sautoy, as we have seen, is one, but also an increasing number of physicists are being seduced into thinking that ‘the principles of mathematics are also the principles of all things that be’, that somehow mathematics is the primary reality or as some might say the supreme force of the universe. Another example of a scientist who has lost sight of reality is I. V. Volovich, a physicist at the great centre for wasting taxpayers' money, CERN. In his paper Number Theory As The Ultimate Physical Theory Volovich concludes that: " ... the fundamental entities of which we consider our Universe to be composed cannot be particles, fields or strings but numbers ..." Obviously the man is daft as a brush, numbers are a construct of the human mind. Numbers are what we use for accounting and measuring. Many things can be said to have divine properties but not abstract concepts like numbers. Others have dived into the same dark pool only to find on braining themselves on the bottom it was not as deep as they thought, for example Vasilios Gardiakos:
"That ‘all is number’ will allow us to create what many theologians thought only God was capable of…all can be numerated and computerized…Mathematics is the most basic requirement for existence. It has no mass, dimension and time and yet it can create these and many more phenomena.
The Thales era which brought us science is near the end. It is to be followed by the Pythagorean era with…the realization that ‘all is number’…we will gain the vision that ‘all is mathematics’…This is the point that we begin to perceive our existence as numerical."
The philosophy of mathematics is pure philosophy and not science as it's devotees like to claim, it proposes, but never resolves. Pythagoreans aim to cut through the debate between the Platonists and the Formalists, the Realists and the Nominalists by making both views redundant through asserting a radical third way, which aims to dominate the whole scientific enterprise. Platonists and Realists believe that mathematical entities exist independently of the human mind, abstract and immutable; apart from this material universe in which absolute mathematical truths reside. In this view, mathematicians do not invent mathematics but discover it. New mathematical concepts are "revealed". But if these entities are not part of this universe, how can they be discovered and recognized? The standard answer to that it is by intuition or (divine?) revelation and illumination, thus we have a dichotomy. The scientists who most despise religion embrace the methodology of the religious thinker as their own. Christians might be attracted to such a view, in that such entities ‘exist’ in the mind of God, (or somehow in God himself, who is transcendently not part of this universe but something which, as one of the gnostic gospels puts it, is so great the entire firmament is contained within it and yet so small it's whole is contained within the smallest thing. Formalists/Nominalists on the other hand deny the existence of mathematical entities, dismissing mathematics a purely a construction of the mind (whether the mind of man or the mind of God). In this view, mathematics is a very useful common language and tool that can help us try to make sense of the world, and can lead us towards beneficial discoveries and enhance our understanding, but which is for all that an artifice, a human invention. St Augustine had some interesting thoughts along these lines as well, that numbers are the universal language conveyed by God to us as confirmation of the truth. Realists and Nominalists are agreed that there are no mathematical entities within this universe, but Pythagoreans assert that mathematical entities are not only within the universe, but actually comprise the universe. This has been an attractive idea for atheist scientists who take a reductionist approach in their efforts to avoid answering the unanswerable questions that are food and drink to philosophers. If everything can be reduced to numbers, everything can be explained by an equation. Except Wayne Rooney's goalscoring ability of course, or how a cat times it's leap to catch a bird that is about to fly away, or how a monkey swings with such apparent ease from branch to branch among the trees while so many humans struggle to solve even simple equations. Realism then proposes that mathematical entities exist outside the reality of the physical universe. The connection, if any, between these entities and reality is an ongoing debate. Nominalism holds that there are no mathematical entities; mathematics is a product of the mind apart from reality. Pythagoreanism: asserts that there are mathematical entities within the universe, which constitute the whole of reality. All else is a product of the mind. St Augustine said, "If you see anything at all that has measure, number, and order, do not hesitate to attribute it to God as craftsman." With those things in mind, imagine the hysterical fury that would come pouring from the mouths and fingers of militant Atheists, if this TV series had been titled "Intelligent Design?" rather than the more cryptic "The Code." while highlighting the intelligence of the design underlying the patterns and numbers of which the universe is formed. ROTFLMAO.
RELATED POSTS:
The Citique Of nate Silver's Pure Reason
Maths Fascism
Laundering Scientific FallaciesFrom climate change to economic chaos, experts can be relied on to get things wrong. Does spending too much time in universities make people stupid or does the computer science used to model reality for fail to distinguish between reality and wishful thinking? This analysis blows apart the business of laundering reality to mask the hoplessness of scientific predictions ...
Science cannot provide all the answers, there is room for faith
Melvin Bragg attacks Richard Dawkins Atheist Fundamentalism
Divinity, Dawkins and A Pope
There Is A War Going On Between Religion And Science. Is A Truce Possible
Dr. Pangloss Said All Is For The Best In This The Best Of All Possible Worlds
Reincarnation: Is There Scientific Proof We Can Live Again? What happens to us after death? It is a question humans have asked since men first stood erect (fnrr, fnrr). Is there scientific proof of reincarnation or are such things just superstitious delusions? All the main religions and there many branches believe something of us survives physical death but is ir possible the non phyical portion of our being (the soul?) can inhabit more than one physical body? Might there be scientific proof of reincarnation?
Getting Started With Existentialism
Theosophy For Beginners The War Between Science and Religion When cosmologist Martin Rees was awarded the Templeton Prize for scientific work enhancing the spiritual side of life the militant atheists reacted with predicatable angry intolderance. Their intolerant attitude seems to have done more to harm the scientific community than to turn paople against faith and religion.
Quantum Metaphysics or The God Experiments
The Flight From FreedomFleeing from freedom seems like a contradiction, after all we usually asdsiciate flight with escaping from captivity. In this first part of Existentialism for Beginners however the author identifies a human instinct that predisposes us to seek illusory safety by conforming and being part of the crowd rather than embarking on the lonely life of the free thinker, the person who truly makes their own decisions and follows their own path.
Not Intelligent Design But A Designer Universe.
Is It Time To Ban Maths From Schools?
You Don't Have To Be Good At Maths To Understand ComputersA recent survey revealed a high number of British adults are poor at mathematics. This is blamed for ourt falling behind in technology related businesses and professions. But it it necessary to be a whizz at quadratic equations to understand computer. Quite the opposite says former Information Systems Management Consultant and hater of abstract maths Ian Thorpe.
Skip RSS Feeds and go to Greenteeth Menu Panel
|
find keywords on this domain This free script provided by
NAVIGATION 
CATEGORIES Ed Butt at Bubblews Boggart Blog Little Nicky Machiavelli Boggart Network News Greenteeth Bites Greenboggart Boggart Blog Central Daily Stirrer briefing Boggart Network News BOGGART BLOG ARCHIVES BBselect002 BBselect003 BBselect004 BBselect005 BBselect006 Spoken Word Video Music Graphic Art
|
|
More From Around The Labyrinth
| LATEST POSTS & COMMENTS
Online shills paid to control your perception by spreading propaganda using up to 10 online personas Is The Truth About Vaccines That Government, Big Pharma And Doctors Don't Want You To Know Emerging At Last? Another Conspiracy Theory Proved True A Disturbing Story From Rawalpindi: Is The Truth About Vaccines Emerging? I wanna be a motivational magician Left behind when the Bilderberg Group checked out Obama Administration Frames Assad As Excuse For Sending US Arms To Al Qaeda Rebels Heart Disease: A Heart Specialist Finally Admits 'The Science Is Wrong. The World has Really Been Turned Upside down When We Look To Russia To Defend Our Rights The Fog In The Ruins: A ghost story by Sharon Pribble Was The Banks' Cypriot Smash And Grab A Rehersal The Perfect Killing Machine University of BC Doctors Expose Vaccination Cover-up: Official Documents Released From The UK Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Sold You Out To Big Government Then Lied To You About It. The Planned Green Holocaust, Depopulation Needed To Save The Planet War On Cash Begins, It Is Not About Keeping You Or Your Money Safe From Muggers Obama Secret Trade Deal That Will Destroy The American Economy Attention Americans. Did you know that your esteeemed President Barack Obama has not been spending all his time goofing around with the gayboys, playing golf and snorting cocaine (OK, these things are only rumours but what else could he be doing while he's not running the country). The President has been busy working on behalf of the people who ... Obama Administration Seizes Cellphone Data - All Your Business Are Belong Us. Nestle Put 53 MILLION per cent mark up on patent water Is The Day Coming When Courts Will Determine Innocence Or Guilt From Brain Scans Bilderberg News No Good Deed Should Go Unpunished Monsanto have tried tyo ram their poisonous G M foods down our throats but even in america where the Genocidally Modified Food corporation have the government, the legal system, education and academics in their pocket, public opinion is still strongly against Frankenstein Food. Now Monsanto are trying to rig the scientific review process. Electronic Tattoos To Replace Passwords and Pin Numbers? Carbon Dioxide Is Greening The Planet, Not Killing It Everything you Do Is A Sign Of Mental Illness Pastor Promised Congregation His Penis Contained Holy Milk Brazilian Evangelical Christian Pastor Valdeci Sobrino Picanto has been arrested after convincing followers of his 'mission' that his penis contained holy milk., "He has been arrested after deceiving the faithful into believing these foolish lies by using the name of the Holy Spirit", one of his victims told Brazilian prosecutors ... Globalisation, Misinformation, Deception, False Store Fronts ... Obama Will Sign U.N. Firearms Treaty After It Was Rejected by Senate Internet Monitoring System To Stalk Social Media Users Who Question Safety Of Vaccines Education Is Out, Indoctrination Is In. Europe Kicks Monsantos Arse Over GMOs Forget Recession, US banks Post Record Profits The Most Secretive And Oppressive regime In The Modern World. What Happened To The Idea Of Financiasl Privacy Time For The New World Order Says U.S. Elder Statesman In the video below, former U.S. Secretary Of State and perpetual Bilderberg Group attendee Henry Kissinger calls for the United States to cooperate with authoritarian regimes such as China to create a globalist totalitarian government. Now maybe those who habitually scream "Conspiracy Theory" The Bio Tech Rape Of India Obama's Lust For War Could Turn Out Very Badly For The West The putative government of Scotland is trying to push tough laws which will appoint to every child a Nanny State nanny to ensure parents and not abusing their kids. If we think in terms of beating and neglect that seems reasonable but when you remember social workers have yelled abuse because parents kept children off school, let them ... The Importance Of Free Speech And A Free Press Rioting In Sweden: Unrest may spread across Europe, warns Red Cross chief Does New Obama Speech Signal The End Of Internet Freedom? Stupid (Swedish) Coppers Of The Week Fail To Quell Stockholm Riots Amsterdam's twin Prostitutes, The Fokkens Twins Retire At 70 Chemical Cosh For Kids That Do Not Conform The Banksters Bullion Heist: How The Gold Market Was Hi Jacked And The Banksters Robbed Us All Fears Of Violence And Unrest As English Town Prepares For Bilberberg Rally Global Warming Theory Debunked By NASA What Is All That Aid Money Really being Used For Angelina's Tits: Was the world too quick to celebrate the unnecessary double mastectomy Prescription of dangerous antidepressants that cause sudden death is rapidly expanding
'The list of antidepressants that can cause sudden death is growing exponentially, with citalopram - under the brand names ...
Two stories that show how the banksters plant to control your cash and how you spend it He Who Controls The Food Controls The Universe. All Your Gene Are Belong Us - You Don't Own Your Body, Obama's Government Does Barack Hussein Obama is rapidly becoming known as the sellout President, he has welched on every electoral promise and bent over backwards (and forwards we hear) to accomodate his corporate paymasters. Well some of us did try to warn you he was The New World Order's houseboy. Now he is even giving the corporations rights over citizens bodies. He Who Controls The Food Controls The Universe Remember that famous line from Frank Herbert's science fiction novels in the Dune series, "He who controls the spice controls the Universe"? Just substitute the word food for spice and the line is starting to look eerily prophetic. Greenpeace the environmental protection group claimed a rare victory against the march of corporate fascism when Washington Signals Fears Over Dollar Economic Insanity: We Spend $11 million to create each green job Lies, Damned Lies and ... umm... Those Other Things ... oh yeah, statistics. Children Given Chemical Cosh For Fictitious Disease Critics of the Ritalin disaster which saw many lived ruined by the prescription of 'bonkers' drug Ritalin for "ADHD" are now getting support from an unexpected quarter. The German weekly Der Spiegel quoted in its cover story on 2 February 2012 the US American psychiatrist Leon Eisenberg, born in 1922 as the son of Russian Jewish immigrants, who was the “scientific father of ADHD” and who said at...
Scientific Dictatorship: The Total Surveillance Society Is Coming Soon. War On Terror, War On Drugs, Jihad Against Junk Food Monsanto Owns The Life Reproducing Process Says U S CourtPoliticised Judges show bias in finding for the Corporate giant and helping advance its agenda to control the food supply. This is the corporation that wants to make sure nobody ever eats ant product, plant or animal, that is not genertically modified. And the shits who have hijecked our societies, the politicians, lawyers, bankers and scientists are happy to sell us out to these fascists and help create their Brave New World. Eat Insectes, good food is only for elitists says United Nations Very survivalist, very Soylent Green. The scientific advisers of that hotbed of elitism where the politicians, international lawyers, bankers and top academics, the U N (United Nazis) has been thinking about the incipient food crisis. And they say the food shopping list of all us ordinary punters in future will include Bread, Milk, Grubs, Beetles, Maggots, Locusts, Worms and Spiders.The Jihad On Junk Food |