logo
Nanny State Has Her Cake And Eats It


Are governments everywhere showing an increasing desire to meddle in the minutae of individual citizens lives or is it just the English speaking world?

Having Your Cake And Eating It- the Nanny State Way
by Ian R Thorpe
2007-01-17

A poll commissioned by the Labour party has revealed that the British public has a mixed attitude to Government. While we demand better public and cheaper services but less Government intervention in our lives.

Is it unreasonable to try to obtain more for less a.k.a. better value for money when our taxes are involved? After all The current Government are dealing with the debt crisis by telling us to tighten our belts and shop around for better value. So are the senior civil servants who received the poll results right to be miffed at our ingratitude? And are we right in thinking that of all European nations we are the most hassled by our government.

Having worked in several European countries I do feel that though most, principally Germany, France, Sweden and Holland have extensive social welfare programmes, the way these are run is less heavy handed and intrusive.

Can it be that the Dutch, Germans, French, Swedes and other only need telling once that smoking is bad for them, that binge drinking is not big and its not clever and that taking drugs is just self destructive. Can it really be that only the British are not capable of thinking for themselves and need a bureaucrat supervising every breath. Or might it be that the goverments of these progressive nations understand that people will be what they will be. No matter how much mkoney and effort is expended to stop people harming themselves by drinking, smoking and eating too much these things will still happen.

I think the problem is a throwback to the class system. The lower end of the middle classes were usually not better off than the more affluent working class families (those where the breadwinner was a craftsman or similar) so they adopted an attitude of moral superiority. There wags an idea of "the undeserving poor," those people so ignorant and irresponsible they had to be saved from their own stupidity.

I suspect in the minds of middle ranking civil servants the idea of the undeserving poor and the need of the self-righteous middle class to wag admonishing fingers at them still exists. It shows itself in the regular appearance of ideas like withholding hospital treatment from drinkers, smokers and overweight people.

Now we can't really blame either party for the Nanny state, they have both contributed to the huge increase in Government snoopers at the expense of professions like nurses, teachers, bus and train drivers, ambulance crews and police and fire officers.

But the lesson that needs to be learned by Nanny is one I had to teach middle managers many times in my career as a management consultant: if you treat people like children they tend to behave like children.

RELATED POSTS: Just Say Grace
The Truth About Education, The Economy, Crime & Everything Else
The Lost Generation
Tommy Clod
You Scumbag, You Maggot, You Cheap, Lousy Meat Product
A Career In Substance Abuse
Dangerous Trees Targeted By Health And Safety Executive
Well We Did Warn You
Suit You Nurse

Government By Fear And Panic
Can Things Get Any Worse
You Live, You Die
Fear And Panic And HP Sauce
Health And Safety Halloween
Spooky Halloween Poems
Halloween Fortnight
Health and Safety - Life Saving Is A Risky Business
Before The Pubs Close
British For Dummies
Government By Fear And Panic
Inspirational Old Queen
Nanny State Has Her Cake And Eats It
National Lottery Mottery

If you liked this, please give it a boost

Bookmark and Share

Close Window and return to menu
INFORMATION & NAVIGATION

navigate

CATEGORIES

Fiction
Wide World - travel
Health / Wellbeing
Nature
Real Lives - biography
Past Perspectives
Philo & Sophia
Fools & Dreamers
Comment & Opinion Faith And Spirituality
Poetry Life And Times
Books
Entertainment
Music
Arts & Crafts
Environment
Food
Science & Tech.
Bog of Blogs

Visit The
BLOG INDEX
and keep up with our
comments around the
web

TAGS
Climate Change
BLOGS
Boggart Blog

Little Nicky Machiavelli

Boggart Network News

BOGGART BLOG ARCHIVES

BBselect001 BBselect002 BBselect003 BBselect004 BBselect005 BBselect006
MULTI MEDIA
Spoken Word
Video
Music
Graphic Art

LATEST POSTS & COMMENTS

BULLETIN
New Posts
Drugs Online
One of the few growth industries is the selling of fake prescription drugs online. So long as the drugs sold as viagra, vallium, ritalin etc are just sugar pills there is no harm done. It's when people buy the real thing the trouble starts...
Slutbot, The Internet Cyberhooker
Men, have you been approached by a slutbot yet. A slutbot is a piece of malwae that arrives liooking like an e mail from a sexy young female who is desperate to have sex with you. Click on a link to find out more however and you invite a worm. trojan or key logger onto your computer where it will steal all your personal data. Unlike a real prostitute however who may give you a social diseas or if you are lucky just a hand job before running off with your money, you are never going to get anything from Slutbot.

Internet Access As A Human Right?
A survey carried out by the BBC found a majority of people around the world believe internet access should be a basic human right. We suspect a bit of statistical rigging because the majority of people in the world live below the poverty line and probably have more urgent priorities than surfing the net.

Dodgy Donor Scandal, As Conservatives Squirm We Name Labour Non Dom
As senior figures in the Labour party continue to milk the issue of Conservative Party donor Lord Ashcroft and his non domiciled tax status Boggart Blog delves into the financial affairs of a businessman who has financial links with the Labour party.

Feng Shui Shite
Whether you are sceptial of all such things or you believe in feng shui ans stuff here's an article that shows people who make their liing selling this shite are just rip off merchants.

Life On Mars
After rubbishing reports of UFOs and alien visitations for years scientists got very excited when they thought they had found water (ice) on the surface of Mars. This indicates that other planets in our solar system miht just be able to support life. Not as good as seeing a flying saucer in your back garden though is it?

B Sc in Stating The Obvious
When The Queen makes her annual speech at the state opening of Parliament everybody knows the text is written for her by government ministers and senior civil servants. What would The Queen say if she could write her own speech?"
The Real Queen's Speech When The Queen makes her annual speech at the state opening of Parliament everybody knows the text is written for her by government ministers and senior civil servants. What would The Queen say if she could write her own speech?"
We Made Love
This poem, with its exquisitely charming video performance is a reflection from middle age on the all consuming madness of young love. With music, Ravel's Bolero, to complement the mood its shows that passion never grows old even if people do.
Play video We Made Love from here.

Them - A poem for the surveillance society
One of the biggest worries to afflict people living in modern economically developed nations is the loss of privacy. CCTV, databases, surveillance technology and internet monitoring contribute to a feeling we are losing our freedom as individuals. This poem by by British poet Ian R Thorpe sums up the zeitgeist. See video "Them" only

GO TO Boggart Blog Back Catalogue for links to older posts

COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDED READING AROUND THE WEB
Your Right To Know The James Bulger muder case has reurned to the forefront of news and looks set to stay there. Should Jon Venables and Robert Thompson ever have been released into society in view of what they did?

Demolishing The Green Jobs Lie As the Church Of Science scream that the Big Oil lobby has crucified their AGW God we find that government policies on "investing in green jobs" are being influenced by big wind, big sun and big carbon capture.

A New E U Treaty. Believe it or not only months after securing the Lison treaty the EU Komissarat is now pushing for a new, further reaching treaty to extend central powers and further erode national sovereignty.

High Priest Of AGW Eats Humble Pie Gerald Warner wallows in schadenfreude as George Monbiot admits AGW and carbon taxes are a lost cause.

Investing In Green Jobs A Waqste Of Time And Money Green Jobs will not save the planet or the economy, in fact investing in green technology will cist jobs and increae inflation.

Europe Racing Towards Dictatorship
The fining of UKIP MEP for saying something the unelected "President" (Kommisar) of the European Union Herman von Rumpuoy - Pumpy tells us all we need to know about the EU attitude to democracy.

Conservative Lead Crumbles Overnight Do the Conservatives have Stockholm Syndrome asks pjc journal? Or are they being coereced into not attacking Labours abysmal record asks The Daily Stirrer

Unsettled Climate Science A level headed assessment of leftist hysteria and attempts to cling to power by spreading fear and panic.

On Obama's Narcissism Salinger had Obie sussed as you can read in this blog.

The Left's Betrayal Of The Working Class ... these mute, angry, unemployable children shame the Left particularly, because they are the product of the Left’s experiments in education, as well as their patronising and controlling attitude to the “lower classes”. ... FOR OLDER COMMENTS from our blog index click here. MORE FAVOURITES

Home
Top Of Page
Back Catalogue
Our Comments
FEATURESThe Daily Stirrer
Boggart Blog Central

Comedy Main
Comic Verse
Cartoons
A Tale Told By An Idiot
General
Fiction
History
Thought
Poetry
Science & Technology
Elsewhere

Boggart Blog Daily
Little Nicky Machiavelli
This writer at Authorsden Gathering
Delicious Greenteeth
Boggart Network News